Dan Liebke's Astonishing Tales

He showed up in the pilot to kill the pilot. At that point, we didn’t know much about the monster other than it had something against Greg Grunberg. Since then, we’ve learned a lot more about it. That it’s made of smoke for one thing. That it’s rather judgmental for another. It’s also able to be repulsed by electric fences and is summoned by Ben emptying his toilet.

But there’s obviously way more to Ol’ Smokey than that. He’s the archetypal Lost mystery – as the writers acknowledged in Season Four when Ben, pleading for his miserable, awesome life, promised to tell Locke anything he wanted to know. Locke’s first (and only) question: “What is the smoke monster?”

Tell me your secrets, Smoke Monster

Of course, we didn’t get an answer at that point because, uh, Ben lied. But we will get an answer in the final season. Right? Right?!?

What Exactly We Need To Know

• Who built the smoke monster?
• What, exactly, is it? (Is it a manifestation of Jacob’s friend from the Season Five finale?)
• Why is it on the island?
• Who controls it?
• How does it decide who it kills and who it does not?

Why The Smoke Monster Question Needs To Be Answered

As mentioned above, it’s the archetypal Lost unanswered question. If they don’t answer this one, then who knows what they’ll answer.

Odds of the Question Being Answered?

42-1 on

Closest thing we have to a certainty on this show. Smokey’s the big question. If they don’t answer that, there will be rioting in the streets (not to be confused with Dancing In The Streets – which is far more pleasant and easier to dance to)

Related Pages

If you hated this, you'll probably also hate:

1. Lost Analysis: Mysteries and Unanswered Questions - Okey-dokey, people. Mysteries. Unanswered questions. Lost. Let’s sort this lot out. At the time of writing, it’s less than twenty weeks until the final season of my favouritest show in...
2. Lost Analysis: Mysteries and Unanswered Questions – Who Is Jacob? - Wow! Didn’t time fly. I had originally said I was going to cover all the major outstanding mysteries and unanswered questions left for Lost on a weekly basis until the...
3. Lost Analysis: Mysteries and Unanswered Questions – How Is Walt Special? - Walt, Walt, Walt. Or, to paraphrase his dad: “Waaaaa-aaaaaa-aaaaaaa-aaaaaaaaaaaaalt!!!” The alleged specialness of Walt was hinted at from very early on – with him summoning birds to their death, seemingly...
4. Lost Analysis: Mysteries and Unanswered Questions – What’s Up With Those Numbers? - 4. 8. 15. 16. 23. 42. Six perfectly common integers. Introduced to the show in Season One, Episode Eighteen as the numbers that won Hurley the lottery and then simultaneously...
5. Lost Mysteries and Unanswered Questions – What’s Killing Pregnant Women? - Pregnant women have played a part in Lost since the initial plane crash. Pregnant men less so (although little known fact I just made up – the inflight movie for...